Pros & Cons of Having Two Insurance Policies

Cartoon of a person sitting at their desk


Let’s face it: medical care can be expensive in the United States, especially if you don’t have insurance.

Having insurance can save you from thousands of dollars in medical costs.

But what about having two insurance policies?

Is that even legal?

The short answer is YES, having two policies is legal, and depending on your coverage, it can be a very smart way to make sure you’re protected across a variety of situations. 

But it’s not all good news: two policies can add a bit of extra work, too.

If you’re feeling lost about what insurance you should get, let’s take a closer look at the pros and cons of having two insurance policies.

Pros of having two insurance policies

1. You get more coverage and protection

Insurance policies don’t cover everything, and that’s where having a second policy can help. By signing up for a second policy, you can fill any gaps in your first policy. Let’s say, for example, that you’re on your spouse’s insurance, but there are limitations and exclusions. If you get a second policy, its coverage can step in where your spouse’s policy falls short. it’s like having a safety net for your safety net!

2. You spread out your risk

Having more than one insurance policy allows you to diversify your risk, just like investing in different stocks to protect your finances. Since you have more coverage and protection than with a single policy, your risk of encountering an uncovered scenario is lower. 

3. You get extra benefits and services

Hold on, there’s more! One of the great things about having two insurance policies is the extra perks and services you can enjoy. Different insurance providers offer a variety of benefits that can come in handy when you need them the most. By having multiple policies, you gain access to a wider range of options for claims, discounts, and customer service. You can choose the best of both worlds, taking advantage of the features and advantages offered by each policy. It’s like having a personalized insurance package tailored just for you, with all the bells and whistles included.

Remember, having two insurance policies isn’t for everyone, and it’s important to carefully consider your personal circumstances and needs. But if you’re looking for more coverage, reduced risk, and some extra perks along the way, having two policies might be a good strategy for you.

Cons of having two insurance policies

Having two insurance policies has its advantages, but there are also downsides. Here are a few things you need to consider before jumping into the realm of dual policies.

1. You pay more

Unfortunately, having two insurance policies means paying two premiums, and that can add up quickly. Not only that, but it’s possible that you’ll have overlapping coverage, and you might end up paying for the same type of coverage twice. Yikes! Make sure to review your budget to ensure that having two policies won’t put you in financial distress.

2. You have a more complicated filing process

Filing claims can be challenging, and having two policies means more paperwork, communication, and time required to sort out the details. There’s also the potential for delays and disputes if your policies have different guidelines or requirements. So, be prepared for a potentially more complex claims process and consider if you’re up for the extra effort and patience it may require.

3. You might get confused by policy conflicts

Having two insurance policies means dealing with double the fine print. Each policy comes with its own terms, conditions, and coverage limitations. It can be a bit overwhelming trying to understand all the ins and outs of each policy. It’s important to read and compare the policies carefully to ensure you fully understand what’s covered and what’s not.

Having two insurance policies isn’t all smooth sailing, and it’s essential to weigh these cons against the pros before making a decision. Remember to consider the increased cost, the potential complexity of the claims process, and the possibility of policy conflicts. By evaluating these factors, you’ll be better equipped to decide if having two insurance policies is the right choice for you.

Factors to consider when deciding between policies

If you’re ok with the pros and cons of having two insurance policies, here are some factors to consider when choosing your two policies:

Your personal circumstances

Your policies will cover you, so it’s important that you reflect on your personal health history, upcoming medical needs, and other unique factors before choosing your plans. We’d recommend thinking about the risks you’re willing to take on and how much money you’re willing to spend. How much coverage do you really need? What can you comfortably afford? Do you need extra protection for any specific illnesses or situations?

The specifics of your two policies

You’re responsible for understanding your coverage under any insurance policy or policies. Look at coverage limits, deductibles, and premiums. Make note of any potential overlaps and gaps between the two policies, then consider how the policies complement each other. There is a happy medium somewhere that strikes the right balance between coverage, cost, and convenience.

Customer service from each provider

Bad customer service adds insult to injury, especially after a medical event. When you’re comparing policies and insurance companies, contact the customer service departments. Support agents are there to help you understand policy details, any obligations that come with having multiple policies, and how to address an issue if one comes up. Make note of your experience with each provider and consider if that’s one you’d be happy with when a medical event already has you stressed.


Having two insurance policies has pros and cons. Taking this route requires careful consideration and evaluation. Remember to consider your personal circumstances, compare policies, and communicate with your insurance providers to make the best decision for your specific needs.

Banner with woman working in warehouse

Subscribe to our newsletter

Do you hustle every day? Join us.
Get the latest gig economy news, tips, and trends–and reach
your personal and professional goals!

Get blog updates

Subscribe to the information that serves you best

[wpforms id="54559"]